The Legacy of India’s No. 4
In Indian cricket, the No. 4 spot in Test matches carries more than just statistical weight—it bears a legacy. First occupied with unshakeable dominance by Sachin Tendulkar, and then by Virat Kohli, it has become a symbol of batting authority, class, and responsibility.
With Virat Kohli currently unavailable for the upcoming India vs England Test series 2025, the question is both urgent and historic: who will replace Kohli at No. 4 in the Indian Test team?
Shubman Gill: The Natural Successor?
Rising Star with the Right Technique
If there’s one name that resonates as a natural heir, it’s Shubman Gill. His textbook technique, elegant strokeplay, and calm temperament have already earned comparisons to some of the game’s greats.
- Pros: Stylish, technically sound, adaptable across formats
- Cons: Still adapting to the middle-order role after being an opener
Gill’s recent transition to the No. 3 slot after Pujara’s exit suggests team management sees him as a long-term anchor. If KL Rahul opens the batting again, there’s a realistic chance Gill could slide into Kohli’s No. 4 position, where he could blossom into a long-term solution.
KL Rahul: The Experienced Option
When it comes to experience and versatility, KL Rahul ticks almost every box. While he has mostly opened in Tests, he has also batted in the middle order and is in good form across formats.
- Pros: Vast experience, strong overseas record, currently in good form
- Cons: Inconsistent as a Test player over the years
If the management decides to open with Yashasvi Jaiswal and Shubman Gill, Rahul could settle into the No. 4 role and bring stability in Kohli’s absence.
Sarfaraz Khan: The Domestic Giant Waiting in the Wings
The Consistent Performer Deserves a Chance
No name has been louder in the domestic circuit over the past three Ranji Trophy seasons than Sarfaraz Khan. With an average well above 70, he has made an unignorable case for selection.
- Pros: Dominant domestic record, hunger for runs, red-ball specialist
- Cons: Lack of international experience, question marks over technique in tough conditions
Sarfaraz’s Test debut has been a long time coming, and the England series might be the perfect opportunity. If India is looking to invest in youth with a red-ball mindset, Sarfaraz could be the bold choice.
Karun Nair: The Forgotten Triple Centurion
A Wildcard Return?
Karun Nair is the only Indian after Sehwag to score a triple century in Tests. However, after that magical innings in 2016, he faded into oblivion due to lack of opportunities and inconsistent form.
- Pros: Proven Test credentials, experience under pressure
- Cons: Out of favour, hasn’t been a regular in domestic headlines recently
Still, if the selectors are looking for a surprise package with a solid technique and past glory, Nair might get a look-in.
India’s No. 4 Dilemma: More Than Just Numbers
Replacing Kohli is not just about filling a vacant spot—it’s about inheriting responsibility, leading the batting group, and absorbing pressure situations. Whoever steps in will have to shoulder enormous expectations.
The selection decision will likely depend on:
- Current form and fitness
- Team balance (opener vs middle-order)
- Opposition and venue conditions
- Long-term vision for India’s Test future
Expert Predictions: What’s Likely?
Given the dynamics, Shubman Gill appears the frontrunner if KL Rahul opens. However, if Rahul is moved down the order, he might directly slot in at No. 4. That leaves Sarfaraz and Nair fighting for a potential debut or recall if an injury or reshuffle opens up more spots.
Probable Top 6 for India vs England Test Series 2025:
- Yashasvi Jaiswal
- KL Rahul
- Shubman Gill
- Sarfaraz Khan / Shubman Gill / KL Rahul
- Rishabh Pant / KS Bharat (wk)
- Ravindra Jadeja / Shreyas Iyer
